Hi @andy ,
With regard to no other users having this issue, I believe that it is as simple as them not having enough replies to notice the the issue. The main dev site I am working on has thousands of replies, so it is plain to see.
I am yet to find a salutation install with many topics, that uses 1.3, to check on other builds by other people. Even this support area version does not use ajax pagination, and I am sure that if you enabled it you’d find the same issue
c) they don’t have 1.3 enabled with ajax pagination.
Thinking about it, I should also mention that when BB Press is not manually installed, and the default BP group forum is installed with BP, then there is no ajax pagination at all, it defaults to the normal paging mechanism.
Once BBPress is installed, then the ajax pagination tries to work, no doubt due to js being wrapped in a conditional block, but fails to update the topic posts.
Programmers at this end say:
The ajax code actually takes name of active tab (in this case ‘forums’ and fetches result matching it and shows result using forums/forums-loop.php). Similarly we have tabs like ‘blogs’, ‘groups’, ‘members’ and here too ajax works fine.
If you see in above URL if you click on next, you will be actually shown next page of FORUM results and not that of topic comments. In theory it has to be like active tab = ‘topics’ and folders should be ‘topics’ and file should be ‘topics/topics-loop.php’.
A test url here is http://bp.weblife.com.au/community/groups/test-group/forum/topic/test-post/
It is running WP 3.3, BP 1.5.2 and theme version 1.3 – all installed just now for this demo purpose.